Nunc Pro Tunc Arguments: Excusing Overstay Time

Nunc Pro Tunc Arguments: How to Excuse Visa Overstay Time

 What Is a Nunc Pro Tunc Request?

Nunc pro tunc, Latin for "now for then," refers to a legal mechanism that allows actions to be applied retroactively. In immigration context, nunc pro tunc arguments ask USCIS to excuse periods of unlawful presence based on circumstances beyond your control.

For athletes and coaches who accumulated unlawful presence due to misleading advice, processing delays, or extraordinary circumstances, nunc pro tunc arguments can provide a pathway to clearing your record.

 When Nunc Pro Tunc Arguments Apply

Not every overstay qualifies for nunc pro tunc relief. USCIS considers these arguments in specific circumstances:

Reliance on Incorrect Legal Advice

If you remained in the United States based on advice from an attorney or accredited representative who provided incorrect guidance about your status, this creates grounds for a nunc pro tunc argument.

Employer-Caused Delays

When employers fail to file timely petitions despite promises to do so, the resulting status gaps may qualify for nunc pro tunc consideration.

Extraordinary Circumstances

Medical emergencies, natural disasters, or other extraordinary circumstances preventing timely departure or filing may support nunc pro tunc requests.

USCIS Processing Errors

If USCIS errors caused your status lapse, nunc pro tunc arguments have particularly strong foundations.

 Building Your Nunc Pro Tunc Case

Successful nunc pro tunc arguments require thorough documentation:

Evidence of Misleading Advice

Text Message Records

Contrary to common belief, text messages serve as valid evidence. Screen captures showing communications where you received incorrect advice about your status directly support your case.

Email Correspondence

Any emails discussing your status, work authorization, or filing timelines help establish what you were told.

Retainer Agreements

Documents showing your professional relationship with the person who provided advice establish their role in your decision-making.

Payment Records

Evidence that you paid for professional services supports your claim of good faith reliance on that advice.

Timeline Documentation

Employment End Dates

Clear documentation of when your authorized employment ended.

Filing Dates and Receipts

All petition filings, receipt notices, and USCIS correspondence.

Decision Notices

Approval and denial notices establishing the official timeline.

Status Calculation

A clear calculation showing the period of unlawful presence you are asking USCIS to excuse.

Good Faith Evidence

Compliance History

Your history of immigration compliance before the incident demonstrates good faith.

Prompt Action

Evidence that you acted promptly once you understood your correct status situation.

No Willful Violation

Documentation supporting that you did not knowingly violate immigration law.

 The "Not a Real Lawyer" Situation

A particularly compelling nunc pro tunc scenario involves discovering your representative was not properly authorized to provide immigration advice.

Notario Fraud

In many countries, "notarios" are licensed legal professionals. In the United States, notary publics have no such authority. Immigrants who rely on notario advice often have strong nunc pro tunc cases.

Unlicensed Practitioners

Discovering your "immigration consultant" was not an attorney or accredited representative supports claims of reasonable reliance on faulty advice.

Documentation Needed

·         Business cards, advertisements, or website content suggesting legal authority

·         Communications where they provided legal advice

·         Evidence of payments made

·         Your lack of knowledge about their actual credentials

 How Nunc Pro Tunc Arguments Are Presented

Nunc pro tunc requests typically accompany new visa petitions:

Include in Cover Letter

Your petition's cover letter should clearly state the nunc pro tunc request and summarize the grounds.

Separate Exhibit

Create a dedicated exhibit with all supporting documentation, clearly organized and labeled.

Legal Brief

A well-crafted legal argument explaining why USCIS should exercise favorable discretion.

Timeline Chart

A visual timeline often helps adjudicators understand the sequence of events.

 Success Factors for Nunc Pro Tunc Arguments

Certain factors increase the likelihood of favorable adjudication:

Strong Documentation

The more contemporaneous evidence you have, the stronger your case. Text messages sent at the time carry more weight than after-the-fact declarations.

Clear Causation

Demonstrating that you would have acted differently with correct information strengthens your argument.

Reasonable Reliance

Your reliance on the advice must have been reasonable under the circumstances.

Prompt Remediation

Taking quick action once you discovered the correct information shows good faith.

Clean Record Otherwise

A history of immigration compliance supports favorable discretion.

 What Nunc Pro Tunc Does and Does Not Do

What It Does:

·         Asks USCIS to excuse the unlawful presence period

·         Can prevent bars from attaching to your record

·         Allows you to proceed with adjustment of status or new petitions

What It Does Not Do:

·         Guarantee approval

·         Restore previous visa validity

·         Eliminate the need for new petition filing

·         Work automatically without proper documentation

 Combining Nunc Pro Tunc with New Petitions

Most athletes present nunc pro tunc arguments alongside new O-1 or P-1 petitions. The strategy typically involves:

Filing a Strong New Petition

Your underlying petition must independently qualify for approval.

Premium Processing

Using premium processing provides a quick answer on whether USCIS accepts your nunc pro tunc argument.

Backup Planning

Having a departure plan if USCIS does not accept the argument protects against accumulating additional unlawful presence.

 When Nunc Pro Tunc May Not Be Enough

Some situations exceed what nunc pro tunc can remedy:

Extended Unlawful Presence

Very long periods of unlawful presence face higher scrutiny regardless of circumstances.

Pattern of Violations

Multiple status violations weaken good faith arguments.

Insufficient Documentation

Without contemporaneous evidence, arguments rest on less compelling foundations.

Willful Conduct

If evidence suggests you knew your status was invalid, nunc pro tunc arguments fail.

──────────────────────────────────────────────────

Nunc pro tunc arguments offer a pathway for athletes who accumulated unlawful presence due to circumstances beyond their control. Proper documentation and presentation significantly impact outcomes.

Related Resources:

·         [Understanding Unlawful Presence](/unlawful-presence)

·         [O-1 Visa Applications](/o1-visa)

·         [Working with Immigration Counsel](/consultation)